Table of Contents
In 2026, the battle for your digital privacy has moved beyond simple encryption. Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark have evolved into comprehensive security ecosystems, launching multi-product "suites" that target every corner of your online identity.
If you are trying to decide between the high-octane ExpressVPN Pro and the feature-packed Surfshark One+, this detailed breakdown will help you choose the right shield for your 2026 digital life.
The Contenders: 2026 Privacy Suites
ExpressVPN Pro: The "No-Compromise" Performance King
ExpressVPN has shed its "VPN-only" skin to offer a streamlined, premium 5-in-1 suite. It is designed for those who want the fastest possible speeds and proprietary tech that "just works".
- ExpressVPN: Powered by the Lightway Turbo protocol, it remains the industry's speed benchmark with 10 Gbps servers in 105 countries.
- ExpressKeys: A standalone, zero-knowledge password manager with biometric unlock.
- ExpressMailGuard: A "VPN for your email" that provides unlimited aliases to stop spam and tracking.
- Identity Defender: Real-time monitoring, credit scanning, and up to $1M in identity theft insurance (U.S. only).
- ExpressAI: A private, end-to-end encrypted AI platform built on Nvidia’s confidential computing architecture.
Surfshark One+: The "All-In-One" Value Titan
Surfshark remains the champion of "more for less," offering a massive array of features and unlimited device connections that make it perfect for households.
- Surfshark VPN: Fast, reliable, and includes "NoBorders" mode for restrictive networks.
- Incogni: A powerful data removal service that automatically requests your info be deleted from data broker databases.
- Alternative ID: A generator that creates entirely new online personas (name, DOB, email) for anonymous sign-ups.
- Surfshark Alert & Antivirus: Real-time breach notifications and lightweight malware protection for all your devices.
- Surfshark Search: A truly private, ad-free search engine that leaves no digital footprint.
Incogni: The Secret Weapon of Surfshark One+
While most privacy suites focus on blocking future tracking, Incogni—the standout feature of the Surfshark One+ plan—focuses on erasing your past.
In 2026, data brokers and "people-search" sites are more aggressive than ever, scraping your home address, phone number, and financial history to sell to marketers or worse. Incogni acts as your personal legal proxy to fight back:
- Automated "Whack-a-Mole": Incogni automatically identifies your data across 420+ data brokers and sends legal opt-out requests on your behalf.
- Continuous Monitoring: Data brokers often re-add your information after a few months. Incogni performs regular re-scans to ensure your data stays off the market.
- Time Savings: Manually opting out of every broker would take hundreds of hours; Incogni handles the entire process in the background while providing progress updates via a centralized dashboard.
- Suppression Lists: A unique 2026 feature is Incogni’s ability to add you to "suppression lists," which tells brokers not to re-profile you even if they find your data again in the future.
Head-to-Head: Feature Comparison
| Feature | ExpressVPN Pro | Surfshark One+ |
| Simultaneous Connections | Up to 14 devices | Unlimited |
| Data Removal | Basic "Identity Defender" (U.S. only) | Incogni (Global, 420+ brokers) |
| Email Privacy | ExpressMailGuard (Unlimited Aliases) | Alternative ID (Aliases + Personas) |
| Password Manager | ExpressKeys (Standalone App) | None (Manual browser storage only) |
| Unique Add-on | ExpressAI (Private LLM access) | Search (Private ad-free engine) |
Pricing: The Bottom Line for 2026
Both providers have shifted toward tiered, long-term plans to offer the best value.
- Surfshark One+: Starts as low as $1.99/mo for a 24-month plan, often including 4 extra months free. It is nearly impossible to beat this price-to-feature ratio.
- ExpressVPN Pro: Positioned as a luxury service at $5.24/mo for 2 years. While more expensive, it includes ExpressKeys and ExpressAI, which Surfshark currently lacks.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose ExpressVPN Pro if...
You are a power user who values speed and simplicity above all else. If you want a built-in password manager and want to experiment with the world's first private-by-design AI, the Pro suite is the best investment for your digital future.
Choose Surfshark One+ if...
You are budget-conscious or have a large family with dozens of devices. If your main goal is to wipe your personal data from the web using Incogni and hide your identity with Alternative ID, Surfshark provides a more "complete" privacy toolkit for half the price.
